Social Security Projections
Over $100 difference between ESP(higher) and AnyPIA from S.S. downloaded program
Seems small, but for me it makes a difference in my planning. I know social security figures a little low but this difference has me question which source to believe. Maybe I'm asking too much & I realize both are just estimates but... Anyone have first hand knowledge in the accuracy of either program to actual payed out benefits?
ESP at 66-2141....S.S.-2037
About same difference at different age/scenarios. I have triple checked all inputs and assumptions and cant see anything that would skew the results.
Maybe split the difference? Answered my own question!
Mon, 07/20/2015 - 14:23
These links may help:
These links may help:
I've seen results within ~$1/month comparing ESPlanner estimates and SS actual benefits.
Mon, 07/20/2015 - 14:49
Is the Alternative II, Intermediate assumptions from the Trustees Report used for the benefits also? That could be the difference also?
Mon, 07/20/2015 - 21:47
Here's our FAQ from Maximize
Here's our FAQ from Maximize My Social Security which uses the same Social Security code as ESPlanner.
Why can't I get Maximize My Social Security's estimates to match the AnyPIA estimates if I'm under age 62?
Maximize My Social Security (MMSS) assumes the real wage growth from the Trustee's report, which we combine with your inflation rate assumption to calculate future nominal average wages.
The closest, but not exactly the same, AnyPIA assumptions are for no benefit increase beginning with the 2014 increase and the 2013 Trustee's Report Alternative II average wage increase. These assumptions use the same real wage growth from the Trustee's report, but combine it with the Trustee's estimated future inflation rates to calculate future nominal average wages and they cause the PIA to be reported in real 2015 dollars.
Because MMSS and AnyPIA use different inflation assumptions they estimate different future nominal average wages, which means that the indexed earnings differ, which, in turn, means the PIAs will also differ.
Changing the inflation rate and nominal rate of return in MMSS does not affect the real wage growth since it comes from the Trustee's report.
So, it's the constant future inflation assumed by MMSS/ESPlanner or the variable future inflation assumed by Social Security Trustees.
Take your pick.
Wed, 07/22/2015 - 10:15
Thanks answered my question.
Good to know.
By using the new inputs for ANYPIA they now match up pretty close. I used Trustees Report Alternative III average wage increase.